Book vs. Movie Review: The Hunger Games

The Book: 2008

I jumped on the Hunger Games Bandwagon shortly after the final book was published.  At first I was resistant to the hype because I’ve been burned before (I’m looking at you, Twilight) but I thoroughly enjoyed this book.  I love science fiction, and this book is science fiction that manages to be highly accessible –  no spaceships or aliens, simply a fascinating dark vision of a future American society, adventure, action, and characters that immediately draw you in.

This story reminded me of other literature that I have loved and that’s definitely not a bad thing.  There’s a little bit of Shirley Jackson’s short story The Lottery, and definitely some Lord of the Flies.  There are many parallels with Battle Royale of course, and all with a modern twist that seems the logical development of our culture’s obsession with reality TV.

Margaret Atwood’s The Handmaid’s Tale also comes to mind.  It tells the story of a woman forced into a subservient and degrading life in a future America which, like the Hunger Games’ Panem, is the result of a mysterious but violent social upheaval.  In this case, the social order is built on religious oppression, whereas in the Hunger Games, society has become a rigidly stratified class system with a dramatically unequal distribution of wealth.  Atwood’s heroine can remember a life before the current regime, and there are hints as to the existence of an outside world.  In the Hunger Games, Panem has been in existence for generations, and our heroine, Katniss, has never known any other way of life.  However, this does not stop her from fighting the system, and her struggle makes for great reading.

 I give the book 5 out of 5 Mockingjays!

The Movie: 2012

I could talk about how elements of the story are always lost in translation and the difficulty in communicating a character’s inner turmoil etc, but I’ll just skip it and admit that this is not how I pictured any of the main characters.  I remember agonizing over casting announcements during pre-production, analyzing photo releases, trying to picture how the different actors would would embody their roles based on their performances in past movies.  In short, I went a little overboard with worry.  But the final product far exceeded my expectations, both as a book adaptation and as a sci-fi adventure film.  I absolutely loved it.

The Pros:

1) The movie takes its time telling the story.  It does not rush through to the violent payoff of the games or give that part of the story more screen time than the less action-packed but no less entertaining character development and political maneuvering that leads up to it.

2) The actors!  They all give excellent performances.  Whenever I reread the book (which I undoubtedly will), I will be picturing these people and hearing their voices.

3) The movie is beautiful.  The cinematography, special effects, makeup and costumes are fantastic.  The contrast between the muted, washed out colors of poverty stricken district 12, the intense greens of the forest just outside the electrified fence surrounding the district, and the elaborate garishness of the Capitol and its residents all serve to convey the rigidly enforced class distinctions in Panem, as well as the harsh limitations faced by those who are not lucky enough to be among the upper class.

These two probably don’t shop at the same store

In the capital, the beard wears YOU

The Cons:

1) The movie really does take its time.  At 2 hrs 22 min, it is not exactly breaking any records for length, but if your personal limit for sitting in a theater seat is around 90 min, this movie will test your fortitude.

2) The actors!  They are so attractive and well groomed.  Certainly none of the main 3 look as if they are barely scraping by (hush now, fangirls – I know Peeta’s family is supposed to be comparatively well off) and even Haymitch, the bitter, drunken, slovenly former champion is just a a quick hair-brushing away from being totally presentable.

From the District 12 fall catalog

“And that’s the last time I ever used conditioner”

3) The franchising.  It really doesn’t have anything to do the movie itself, but I’m just not sure how I feel about this… Ok, maybe jealous that I didn’t think of it first?

This is an actual thing

I give the movie 6 out of 5 Mockingjays for completely exceeding my expectations!

 

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s